Surprise as Richard Dunn building listed

From Bradford Telegraph and Argus:

The iconic Richard Dunn Sports Centre, which was due to be demolished later this year, has been given listed status by Historic England.

The heritage body has described the cavernous domed building, which shut as a leisure centre in 2019, as a “bold and accomplished design for a 1970s local leisure.”

The listing throws the future of the site into doubt, as it means the building is now among the most protected structures in the city.

The Twentieth Century Society, which campaigns for the preservation of buildings constructed after 1914, made a request to Historic England to have the building listed.

Today the organisation announced that this request had been successful, and it was now a Grade II listed building.

The Twentieth Century Society said the building, which was famous for its popular water slides, had a “bold architecture” and was one of the earliest buildings to be designed using computer technology.

Bradford Council had announced plans to redevelop the site once the building was demolished. Originally the plan was to sell the site, and in 2018 the authority began marketing the 6.8 hectare site as Odsal District Retail Centre in a brochure that was handed out to international developers at a real estate conference in Cannes.

But in early 2020 the Council said it would keep the land, which it viewed as a “strategic site for the wider district.”

Before listing the building, Historic England consulted Trevor Skempton, the architect who designed the leisure centre, and Dr Otto Saumarez Smith, an architectural history professor with expertise in leisure-centre history.

They both praised the building, with Mr Skempton saying it was designed to have an “intentional theatrical aspect of the single open space, viewable from the access bridge, which enhanced the sporting experience.”

Bradford Council had written to Historic England to raise a number of issues with the building, including “high running costs when in use; a large maintenance backlog; a shortfall of the existing design against various current standards for access and energy efficiency; ongoing costs of mothballing the building; the budgetary assumption that capital receipts from sale of this site would contribute towards the cost of the replacement facilities; and the likely high costs should the building need to be reconnected to utilities.”

Summing up the listing, Historic England said: “The Richard Dunn Sports Centre is a bold and accomplished design for a 1970s local leisure.

“Its striking ‘big-top’, lattice-girder roof is of particular note.

“Conceived at a time when architectural expression for the building type was the exception rather than the rule, this example stands out within the national context, and has survived well, with its design intention entirely legible.

“Listing is therefore recommended at Grade II.”

A spokesperson for Bradford Civic Society said: “The decision to award listed status to Richard Dunn is an interesting and surprising one, especially given that permission had already been given for its demolition.

“It means Richard Dunn is now only one of a tiny minority of mid 20th Century listed buildings in Bradford, alongside Sunwin House.

“Bradford Civic Society has been increasingly vocal about the need to recognise the contribution made by 20th Century architecture in Bradford, as demonstrated through our debates on High Point and our upcoming event on post-war architecture in the city centre. There is certainly a growing appetite for such buildings.

“The decision is somewhat surprising given that Historic England rejected a similar application to list Arndale House on Market Street which, in the view of our experts, is a very compelling candidate for protected status.”